Hospitals are increasingly relying on travel nurses to address staffing shortages. Although travel nurses often come with a higher financial cost compared to staff nurses, the utilization of travel nurses has been sporadically linked to suboptimal patient outcomes, as per limited research findings.
Travel nurses play a crucial role in bridging the gaps in hospital staffing. However, concerns have been raised regarding their impact on patient outcomes. For decades, healthcare providers have relied on travel nurses to address temporary nursing shortages, and this reliance is only growing. Therefore, it is imperative for healthcare providers to fully comprehend the potential implications on patient care.
A recently published systematic review sought to shed light on the relationship between travel nurses and patient outcomes. However, the findings were inconclusive. While the use of travel nurses may be associated with certain adverse events in patient care, it is important to recognize that these events could stem from wider issues related to hospital staffing and the work environment.
Interestingly, the review revealed limited or negligible impact on patient falls, medication errors, and patient satisfaction. However, there was a consistent correlation between the presence of travel nurses and hospital-acquired pressure ulcers, the severity of medication errors, and the incidence of nosocomial infections (commonly known as healthcare-associated infections).
In light of these findings, it becomes imperative for hospitals to explore ways to better accommodate travel nurses in order to minimize any potential effects on patient outcomes. By doing so, we can ensure the well-being and safety of both patients and healthcare professionals alike.
What Is a Travel Nurse?
Travel nurses are a vital solution to staffing gaps in hospitals, often embarking on shorter-term assignments that require them to travel out of town or state. While their primary role is to fill in for absent staff members due to various reasons such as vacation, parental leave, or illness, travel nurses also play a crucial role in alleviating nursing shortages.
One of the reasons travel nurses earn higher salaries compared to staff nurses is the additional stress associated with traveling, being away from home, and the lack of benefits. Adaptability is a key trait for travel nurses as they must quickly adjust to new situations, procedures, and colleagues. Registered nurses can pursue travel nursing either as independent agents or through a travel nurse agency.
According to the American Hospital Association, the percentage of total hours worked by travel nurses in relation to hospital nurses has grown significantly, from 4% in January 2019 to 23% in January 2022. This highlights the increasing reliance on travel nurses in the healthcare industry.
How Does Patient Care Differ Between Traditional and Travel Nurses?
Based on the review, there is a clear and consistent relationship between staffing levels and patient outcomes. It comes as no surprise since travel nurses are often hired to address low staffing levels in hospitals. A qualitative study also provides strong evidence-based support for the association between nursing staff levels and patient outcomes.
According to the systematic review, staffing levels were identified as the key factor impacting patient outcomes. Notably, there was no consistent correlation found between the use of permanent/traditional nurses versus travel nurses and certain patient outcomes. These outcomes include:
- Patient falls
- Number of medication errors
- Patient satisfaction
However, some negative outcomes did show a consistent correlation with the use of travel nurses. These include:
- Hospital-acquired pressure ulcers
- Severity of medication errors
- Nosocomial infections (healthcare-associated infections)
Due to the limited research on patient outcomes and travel nursing, the systematic review encompassed a mere 21 articles. Several reviewed studies focused on only a couple of patient outcomes, and interestingly, findings for the same outcome often varied. Notably, some studies revealed improved outcomes for specific variables with increased utilization of travel nurses. However, further research is imperative to gain a comprehensive understanding of the correlation between the employment of travel nurses and patient outcomes.
How Can Hospitals Better Accommodate Travel Nurses?
The review also explored the influence of hospital structures, patient risk factors, and travel nurse experience levels on patient outcomes. Ultimately, the study revealed a strong correlation between the work environment and quality of patient care.
Interestingly, the study did not consistently find a correlation between the type of unit (e.g., critical care) and outcomes, or between patient risk factors and travel nurse experience levels in relation to patient outcomes. However, some studies in the systematic review suggested that the work environment may be the determining factor in whether the use of travel nurses is associated with adverse patient outcomes.
Factors associated with a positive work environment include, but are not limited to:
- Appropriate level of challenges
- Autonomy
- Career advancement
- Collaborative work environment
- Control over work environment
- Manager support
- A non-punitive environment
- Nurse input into error prevention
- Job satisfaction
- Patient-centric culture
- Perception of being valued by leadership
- Support for education and development
- Workplace civility
The utilization of travel nurses may be influenced by the work environment and staffing levels in hospitals. If permanent staff perceive inadequate staffing levels or an unsupportive work environment, they are more inclined to leave. Negative work environments can contribute to the nursing shortage, resulting in an increased reliance on travel nurses. It is plausible that the work environment and staffing levels are the root causes when adverse outcomes appear to be associated with travel nurses.
Further research reveals additional insights and trends that are shaping the travel nursing landscape in 2024:
- Technological Integration and Personalized Medicine: Travel nurses are increasingly benefiting from advancements in technology, such as telehealth services, which allow them to provide remote healthcare, enhancing accessibility and efficiency. Personalized medicine, focusing on individual health needs and medical history, is also becoming more prevalent, leading to improved diagnoses and patient experiences.
- Recruitment and Work-Life Balance: There is a shift towards more personalized recruitment strategies to better match travel nurses with suitable placements. Also, there is an increasing emphasis on work-life balance for travel nurses, acknowledging the emotional toll of their profession and the importance of preventing burnout.
- High Demand and Competitive Compensation: The demand for travel nurses remains high due to staff turnover and shortages in healthcare. Consequently, compensation packages for travel nurses continue to be competitive, often including attractive salaries, sign-on bonuses, housing stipends, and benefits.
- Specialization and Diversity Initiatives: There is a growing need for nurses with specialized training in areas like emergency room, critical care, and oncology. Healthcare organizations are also focusing on diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, ensuring fair hiring practices and an inclusive work environment.
- Positive Impact on Patient Outcomes: Travel nurses, with their diverse experiences and adaptability, have been found to positively impact patient outcomes. They help address staffing shortages, bring varied skills and expertise, and improve patient satisfaction. Additionally, travel nurses are often required to have significant bedside experience, which aids in navigating new healthcare settings and managing complex patient scenarios.
- Systematic Review Findings: A systematic review highlighted that the relationship between travel nurses and patient outcomes is complex and not consistently established. Adverse associations may reflect broader issues like staffing levels or work environments rather than the specific care provided by travel nurses. The review urges healthcare administrators to assess staffing and work environments when employing travel nurses.
In conclusion, while the utilization of travel nurses is crucial in addressing staffing shortages and maintaining patient care standards, the industry is evolving with new trends like technology integration, personalized medicine, and a focus on work-life balance. These developments, along with ongoing research into their impact on patient outcomes, are crucial in shaping the future of travel nursing and healthcare delivery.
Best States To Work As A Nurse Practitioner (NP)
Nursing Fundamentals: Building a Solid Foundation
Cracking the Code: Unraveling the Mechanics of Dual Degree Nursing Programs